Is Tesla still the top EV choice? Discover how the Nissan ARIYA challenges the Model Y with sleek design, strong value, and everyday practicality.
If you’ve been looking for a crossover EV, you’re probably familiar with the Tesla Model Y. However, plenty of great Tesla alternatives are in this category, too — from the Kia EV6 and Hyundai Ioniq 5 to the Ford Mustang Mach-E. But if you haven’t considered the Nissan ARIYA yet, you could be sleeping on the perfect crossover EV.
Tesla may have popularized the electric car, but the Nissan ARIYA brings fresh competition to the table. So, if you’re looking for a head-to-head comparison of the Nissan ARIYA vs Tesla Model Y, look no further. Whether you’re seeking cutting-edge tech, impressive performance, or just a comfortable, reliable ride, we’ll walk you through how these two electric crossovers stack up.
| Feature | 2025 Nissan ARIYA Engage FWD | 2025 Tesla Model Y Long Range RWD |
| Starting MSRP (Before available incentives) | ~$39,770 | ~$46,880 |
| Estimated Range | 216 Mile Range109 MPGe City94 MPGe Highway101 MPGe Combined | 337 Mile Range134 MPGe City117 MPGe Highway125 MPGe Combined |
| Drivetrain | Front-Wheel Drive (FWD) – E-4orce AWD Options Available | Rear-Wheel Drive (RWD) – Dual Motor AWD Options Available |
| Home Charging Time @ 240v | 10 Hours | 12 Hours |
| Performance | 214 Horsepower221 Pound-Feet (lb-ft) of Torque | 342 Horsepower310 Pound-Feet (lb-ft) of Torque |
| 0-60 mph Time | 7.1 Seconds | 6.5 Seconds |
| Cargo Space | 22.8 Cubic Feet (cu ft) | 34.3 Cubic Feet (cu ft) |
| Cabin Features | Leatherette UpholsteryLeather-Wrapped Steering WheelHeated Front SeatsHeated Rear SeatsHeated Steering WheelSeats 5 People12.3” Infotainment Display | Synthetic Leather UpholsteryHeated Front SeatsHeated Rear SeatsHeated Steering WheelSeats 5 People15” Infotainment Display |
| NHTSA Overall Crash Test Rating/Recalls | Five Stars – 0 Recalls | Five Stars – 2 Recalls |
| Warranty | Basic: 3 Years/36,000 MilesDrivetrain: 5 Years/60,000 MilesBattery: 8 Years/100,000 Miles | Basic: 4 Years/50,000 MilesDrivetrain: 8 Years/120,000 MilesBattery: 8 Years/120,000 Miles |
There’s no denying that the Tesla Model Y shines in the estimated range category with 337 miles on a single charge, compared to the 216 miles of the ARIYA. Combined with access to Tesla’s Supercharger network, the Model Y is excellent for long-distance travelers.
That said, most EV buyers don’t buy these vehicles for their long-distance range — they buy them for environmental impact and cost savings. When you consider that most daily drivers and commuters drive less than 40 miles per day, the ARIYA’s 216 miles of range is more than enough for a week of errands or a weekend getaway — and with a faster home charging time (10 hours vs 12 hours at 240 volts), it’s plenty for most drivers.
Plus, with more EV adoption, the charging game is changing. Nissan ARIYA drivers have access to a growing network of public fast-charging stations, and with new agreements allowing non-Tesla EVs to access Superchargers using North American Charging Standard (NACS) ports or adapters, ARIYA owners may soon benefit from even broader access, including many Tesla sites.
Inside, both vehicles come with the trim you expect from this price range. Power windows, Android/Apple smartphone compatibility, power-adjust seats, etc. Both the Model Y and ARIYA seat five (7 seater variants are also available) and come with heated front and rear seats, a heated steering wheel, and high-quality materials. The Model Y’s minimalist dash is anchored by a single 15-inch touchscreen, which is aesthetically pleasing, but may take time to adjust to if you’re used to physical controls.
The ARIYA, on the other hand, offers a driver-focused layout with a 12.3-inch infotainment display and traditional cabin elements. It also includes a leather-wrapped steering wheel, making it feel premium without being overwhelmingly futuristic.
So far as cargo space goes, the Tesla is the winner here, with 34.3 cu. ft. of cargo space compared to the ARIYA’s 22.8 cu. ft. Still, the Nissan ARIYA is no slouch when it comes to everyday usability. 22.8 cubic feet is still a lot of space, especially if you’re used to sedans or coupes. Not to mention, that space is well-shaped, so it easily handles groceries, strollers, luggage, and outdoor gear.
At nearly $7,000 less than the Model Y (when comparing the most budget-friendly models), the 2025 ARIYA offers an attractive starting price, especially when you consider that it’s packed with comparable features. And for those who want a bit more performance or luxury at the wheel, the price difference stays fairly similar as you upgrade trim levels. Choosing the Nissan ARIYA over the Tesla means that the money you save up front can go toward a home charging unit, helpful accessories, or funds for your next road trip.
Performance-wise, the Model Y’s rear-wheel drivetrain, 342 hp, and 6.5-second 0–60 time offer a sportier feel. However, the ARIYA’s 214 hp and 7.1-second 0–60 time are nothing to scoff at either, and are more than enough for the average driver. Plus, the ARIYA’s front-wheel drivetrain makes it a stable and predictable choice for most conditions. Still, for drivers who want the most performance and stability out of their vehicles, both models come in all-wheel drive, dual motor variants, too.
Both vehicles come equipped with advanced safety features like automatic emergency braking and have earned 5-star safety ratings. Still, the Ariya currently stands out with zero recalls, compared to two for the Model Y — an essential factor if dependability and post-purchase confidence matter to you.
Warranty Comparison:
While Tesla’s warranties are longer, Nissan’s dealership network, compared to Tesla’s direct-to-consumer model, can give you more options for local support, parts, and service, so you’re not left waiting if something goes wrong.
This wouldn’t be a comprehensive comparison if we didn’t address brand perception. After all, when it comes to brand recognition in the EV space, Tesla is undeniably a pioneer. Known for pushing the envelope in technology, range, performance, and style, the Model Y benefits from the company’s cutting-edge image and devoted fan base. For many, Tesla represents the future of driving — minimalist, software-driven, and unapologetically bold.
But innovation doesn’t tell the whole story. Nissan has been a global automotive leader for decades, bringing proven reliability, long-term support, and real-world value. In fact, the Nissan LEAF was one of the world’s first mass-market fully electric cars. Nissan has a deep track record in EV development, serviceability, and battery longevity. With the ARIYA, Nissan combines its rich engineering heritage with forward-looking design and tech, resulting in a vehicle that feels simultaneously fresh and familiar.
So, if you’re choosing between the ARIYA and Model Y, it’s worth asking: Do you want a brand that’s trendy and fast-moving, or one that’s steady, service-backed, and built on decades of customer trust?
Choosing your first electric vehicle is a big step, but the Nissan ARIYA makes it easier with its balance of performance, technology, and everyday affordability. With an impressive range, cutting-edge features, and a more approachable price, the ARIYA is one of the best Tesla Model Y alternatives. Experience it for yourself — schedule a test drive at Ed Hicks Nissan and see why the future of EV driving is already here.
